Peer to Peer returns put cash NISAs to shame

EDP desk pic Aug 2014Many people will have put their savings in new cash based NISAs in the last few months to save paying tax on their interest but despite this benefit they will be dismayed with the level of returns currently on offer.

Unfortunately for savers the ISA market mirrors the depressing outlook for the savings market as a whole.

With rates at rock bottom and further cuts taking place every week maybe now’s the time to look at an alternative and more lucrative home for your savings such as peer to peer lending.

The returns from peer to peer providers look more appealing than ever, with RateSetter for example offering 3.7% for a 1 year bond as I write this. Even when you deduct 20% tax, the net return is 2.96% AER and is in a different league from the best 1 year fixed rate ISAs from Tesco Bank and Post Office paying just 1.65% and 1.70% respectively.

In cold hard cash terms 1.70% interest on the maximum cash NISA allowance of £15,000 would give you a net annual return of £255 compared with a far healthier £444 net from the RateSetter 1 year bond option.

With an ISA people will quite rightly point out that you can ring fence your savings from the taxman for this and future tax years something not currently available with a peer to peer provider, however if industry mumblings are to be believed this may well be something that changes in the not too distant future.

However if it’s the level of net interest earned that’s important to you then peer to peer wins hands down, plus you’re not restricted to a maximum annual allowance as with a NISA so if you wanted to save £20,000 or even £50,000 that’s an option.

One of the main concerns with people depositing their cash with peer-to-peer providers is that although the returns far outweigh those paid by the banks, they don’t offer the cast iron guarantee to savers that bank customers enjoy under the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.

As long as you fully appreciate and are comfortable with this, lower overheads of not having to run a nationwide network of branches, means you can obtain better returns on your cash in the peer-to-peer market.

Providers have their own methods in place to depositors. RateSetter for example maintains a ‘provision fund’ with a balance of more than £8.2 million built up from borrower fees. The fund is used to reimburse lenders in the case of late payment or default.

This safety net has ensured since it started almost four years ago, every penny of capital and interest has been returned to every single Lender. Zopa also operates a similar model with its Safeguard feature.

Peer to peer is here to stay and as long as providers keep rates competitive and bad debt levels under control, there’s no doubt in my mind that P2P will become an even bigger thorn in the side of the traditional banks.

If you’re fed up with the miserly bank and building society tax free deals this year, maybe it’s time to look elsewhere..

1 Comment on Peer to Peer returns put cash NISAs to shame

  1. I quite agree that “peer to peer” offer much better savings rates than banks and building societies. I’ve put a little into the big three: Funding Circle, Zopa and Rate Setter. My only worry is the lack of protection from the Financial Services Compensation Scheme – which is what prevents me from saving more money with the peer to peer lenders.

    Should you have a business, the peer to peer accounts are also a good place to save cash. Business savings accounts with traditional banks have worse returns than personal savings; and the peer to peer lenders don’t deduct tax at source, which makes them ideal for businesses.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


%d bloggers like this: